Hertz Pays $1.55 Million for Ignoring Browsers That Said ‘Don’t Track Me.’ Here Is California’s Case, Step by Step
California’s privacy regulator fined Hertz $1.55 million for failing to honor automatic opt-out signals and making it harder for customers to stop the sharing of their data, and ordered retailer Filson to halt ad-tech data sharing. We walk through what the state alleged, what Hertz must now do, and why website owners everywhere should check their tracking setup.
California’s privacy regulator has put another household name on notice over the trackers running on its websites. The California Privacy Protection Agency, known as CalPrivacy, announced a $1.55 million fine against The Hertz Corporation on Tuesday, along with a long list of required fixes. Hertz agreed to the fine and to change its practices, according to a court filing the regulator shared. Our walkthrough draws on The Record’s report and CalPrivacy’s announcement.
1. The signal at the center of the case
Opt-out preference signals are automated messages that a browser or device sends to every website a person visits, telling it not to sell or share their personal information. Under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), businesses are expected to treat that signal as a valid opt-out request.
2. What CalPrivacy said Hertz got wrong
The agency’s enforcement division alleged three problems: Hertz did not process those signals, did not tell consumers how it handled them, and added unnecessary friction to its opt-out process. The case covers Hertz and its Thrifty and Dollar brands.
3. The penalty
Hertz will pay $1.55 million. Some early headlines rounded the figure to $1.5 million. A Hertz spokesperson did not immediately respond to The Record’s request for comment.
4. What Hertz must do every quarter
- Test the methods consumers use to submit CCPA requests to make sure they actually work.
- Keep an inventory of tracking technologies and review any new one before it goes onto the Hertz, Thrifty or Dollar websites and apps.
- Test that opt-outs are honored in both staging and production, across different browsers and mobile platforms, and in every tag management container.
- When publishing its CCPA request statistics, report how many opt-outs came in through preference signals.
5. The regulator’s message
Lara Kehoe Hoffman, CalPrivacy’s acting deputy director of enforcement, said businesses have been on notice for years that the agency expects them to listen when Californians say no to trackers, and that companies cannot ignore those choices or shift responsibility to others.
6. A second company, a stricter order
In a separate decision, the board ordered outdoor clothing maker and retailer CC Filson Co. to stop all device-based sales and sharing of Californians’ personal information with advertising technology companies within 30 days, until it can certify compliance with detailed obligations that include audits, tests and training. Filson will pay $217,987; CalPrivacy said that amount reflects confidential financial information showing the company could not pay a multimillion-dollar fine.
7. What comes next
California’s Opt Me Out Act takes effect in January 2027 and will require browsers operating in the state to offer easy-to-use opt-out signals. That should make these signals far more common, which means more website visitors sending a request that sites are legally expected to honor. CalPrivacy’s recent actions also include fines against FedEx, Tractor Supply and PlayOn Sports.
What this means for your company
If your website serves California residents and your business meets the CCPA’s thresholds, the same rules apply to you, and this case shows the regulator is checking the technical details, not just the privacy policy. Even if you are not covered, other states are adopting similar laws. Most small businesses never chose their trackers deliberately; they arrived with an analytics tool, an ad pixel, a chat widget or a marketing plugin. Take an inventory of every script and pixel on your site, confirm your consent or cookie tool actually responds to browser opt-out signals, test it from more than one browser and on mobile, and make whoever manages your website or marketing responsible for reviewing new tags before they go live. Then document that you did it.
If you do not know which trackers are running on your website or whether they respect visitors’ opt-out choices, we can help you find out and fix it. Reach out to Layer 7 Data Solutions to discuss how we’ve helped companies similar to yours.
